Students
can earn Deputy TaxDetective®
status
... and
have fun while they learn about
tax
How
can students learn about
tax?
-
By
doing sample tax
returns. TurboTax®
or UFile® are both available
online and they are both
free for students to use in
the computer lab or at home.
Students can use a fake
SIN#. The secret is that it
isn't necessary to pay until
(or if) you file the return,
which of course, they won't
be doing.
-
By using
case studies.
Stories are still the
best way to learn, see
the case studies below. Then
it's possible to change the
return to see what happens
'if'' and how the tax
payable or refundable
changes as a result.
-
By
reading real life
tax stories. CANLII
is an organization that has
made it their mission to
make those stories (they
call them
judgements) available at
www.canlii.org
-
My new Student WorkBook allows
students to work in the 'cloud', so
there's no need to prepare a lab,
all that's required is an internet
connection. Students save their work
to the 'cloud' and then access any
computer with an internet connection
to continue their work.
Why would I want to teach kids about
tax?
Because learning about tax,
it's how most of us got the big picture
about how people earn a living. They
see the various categories, consider the
options, and just maybe, a light goes
on.
Most
of us learn about tax after high
school, taking tax courses, at a
local college, or through the
CGA program.
The
basic course on personal tax
is 10 lessons.
The advanced
course about corporations, tax
free rollovers, shareholder
loans and benefits,
partnerships, trusts and death,
is 10 more
lessons.
After
that, you're an expert
(ha).
CRA
did a survey to learn about
young adults and their knowledge
about tax: CRA: YA and taxes
(prepare to be depressed).
I
read this report
and decided
to create a curriculum about
learning tax. My criteria, it
had to be hands on, and there
had to be stories; and it had to
be fun.
To
my surprise, my husband, who
teaches high school math in
Vancouver informed me he is
responsible to teach tax as
a part of the math
curriculum. What's included
is very basic,
there's little time devoted
to tax.
There's
a module on preparing a
paycheque, a T4Slip and a T1
personal tax return. If
you're lucky, a 90 minute
lesson.
I
offered to take his Math
11 Essentials class
through an online
discovery in a computer
lab with Intuit's
TurboTax® and UFile®
software both free and
online.
Word
spread. Other students,
Grade 12's and staff
from the admin office
appeared in the doorway,
asking to join. Soon
every computer in the
lab was in use. Tax was
a pretty hot topic,
especially for kids who
work after school
and tax was being taken
off their paycheques. We
were able to help by
introducing TD1's and
how they
work.
Here's
what happened in the 90
minute lab
Registering
each student for access took 10
minutes. Each student
registers, which requires access
to an email address (they can
all use the same one), sets up
their unique User ID
and password, chooses and
answers a skill testing
question.
Then
they set up their fake tax
return with a fake SIN#.
You
can use the basic exercise from
the textbook T4 if you
want. After that, it was an easy
step to
playing 'what-if'. Imagination
took over as they made
up stories to create tax
returns.
The 90
minute class was over almost
before it started. This
experience inspired me to create
a Student WorkBook, some case
studies, and videos to walk
students and their teachers
through the process, step by
step, to introduce this idea to
teachers at their financial
literacy PD day on
Friday.
The
Student WorkBook has Basic Case
Studies like these:
-
Student,
paper route, mom drives on
rainy mornings, sister helps
out
-
Student,
works at MacDonalds as a
cashier
-
Student,
works as waitress in pizza
parlor, tips, no tax taken
at source
-
Student:
away at University, moves
home for summer job, moves
back to go to
school
-
Young
Adult: first full time
job
Click
here to find Links
to Resources for
Five Basic Case
Studies
The
Student WorkBook will have links
to videos explaining how to log
in, showing step by step
instructions, plus a video of
each case study will walk the
teacher through the case study.
Teachers may use the videos to
walk the class through or leave
the students to work on the
cases independently. The videos
can be provided to students
through the school
library.
Students will
be able to access the videos to
learn about tax by watching
someone do tax, and then by
working in the free software at
their school computer lab or on
their library or home computer.
In the
Student WorkBook, there are five
case studies, links to the video
for each case, links to
reading/resources, questions for
students to answer and solutions
to those questions.
Links
to the resources will be found
on a separate webpage to
facilitate correction of links
gone bad as is wont to happen
from time to time on government
websites. (See link to separate
page)
The Student
WorkBook uses the
internet in real time.
Students work in the
'cloud', so there's no
need to prepare a lab,
all that's required is
an internet connection.
Students save their work
to the 'cloud' and
then access any computer
with an internet
connection to continue
their work.
I've
thought about creating an
advanced Workbook (but only if
there are orders in advance as
each case takes a few hours)
Samples
of potential Advanced Case
Studies
-
Teacher,
single parent with child
& mother lives with
them
-
Teacher,
married with spouse/partner
in University, student
loans
-
Inventor
earns a million dollars, has
surgery in
Texas
-
Dad
works full time, Mom runs a
daycare, family has tenant
in the basement
suite
-
Senior,
single, pensions &
dividends, can't walk, lives
in retirement
home
What
are some other ways to learn
about preparing
taxes?
Teachers
are encouraged to register their
school at
www.intuiteducation.ca. Intuit
Canada provides a class set of
educational software and
everything needed to set up a
lab, including special
installation key codes for the
computer lab.
This
approach requires lab
preparation time.
The
Intuit education package
utilizes older software
versions. If internet connection
speeds from your internet
provider are slow and causing
the students frustration, this
may be an excellent
alternative.
UFIle®
also provides free student
access and a sample SIN #. It's
a great idea to compare and
contract how the two software
work to determine which suits
you best.
CRA programs
for learning
CRA educator
products
Once
you complete the questionaire,
This
page appears with the three
programs
Here's
the course overview for learning
about taxes
Keep reading right to the bottom
of
this page to go more
indepth:
1.
Explore
how various government
Ministries interact to
create and administer
tax
2.
Explore the Income
Tax Act and
Regulations
3.
Review
the authorization process,
My Account and Represent a
Client
Can
you access Income Tax
law?
Yes,
you can. The Income Tax Act is
found on the Minister of
Justice's website.
You
can hunt through the Table of
Contents to find a section, or
you can change the address right
at the end, to change to the
section you want to see (there
are 248 sections).
Here's
the link to section-1, all
that's required is to
click
the link, and then edit the
section number, for example,
edit the -1 and make it -2 or
-69 or -118.2 (medical
expenses)
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-3.3/section-1.html
The
Act comes with ancillary
Regulations found here and note
that it's by page, so changing
the page # will move you
through, as will the Table of
Contents
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/C.R.C.,_c._945/page-1.html
Page 121 is where you'll find Regulation
5700 with a listing of the medical
devices and equipment referenced by S.
118.2(2)(m)
Page 122 is where you'll find Retention
of Books and Records in Regulation 5800
Supreme
Court in Canada Trustco case,
explained that the Income Tax
Act should be read in such as
way as to concern ourselves with
content, context
and purpose. That requires
knowledge about how the Act is
constructed in total, how each
part relates to the other and
why it was set down as law in
the first place. That's a tall
order.
You
could think of the Income Tax
Act as an algebraic formula
written in prose. The same
formulas appear over and over
again. Reading it out loud
helps, and it's important to
always look for the mathematical
connecting words
Those
little connectors, like
"Or",
"And", "Less" and "the Sum of"
help us determine the formula to
use.
Tax
Research Education
The
rest of this page is for
teachers who want more than just
an hour in the computer lab to
learn how the software works and
to play what-if.
What
follows is a complete curriculum
outline for learning about our
taxation system and how we
communicate about
tax. The
following activities engage
students in planning,
mathematics, law and
internet research while
exploring taxation in
Canada.
—Target
age range is 16-18 (grades 10 to
12)
—These
activities allow for creative
exploration of government
websites, and can be used
individually or
sequentially.
—These
activities may be assessed using
the provided evaluation tools.
Where possible, suggestions for
modifications are
provided.
Learning
Outcomes
-
Explore
how Finance, Justice and
Canada Revenue Agency
interact
-
Explore
the Income Tax Act and
Regulations
-
Explore
how tax law is applied to
real people in Tax and
Supreme Court cases
-
Open
your own tax history using
"My Account"
-
Learn
how to research tax
questions
Curriculum
Connections
Course
Content
-
Finance
-
Parliament
-
Justice
-
FINTRAC
-
Courts
-
Canada
Revenue Agency
-
Tax compliance
software
-
Researching
tax questions
-
Non
compliance =
convictions
-
Voluntary
disclosures, penalties and
interest, civil
penalties
Activities:
How laws
are made: (Let's follow the TFSA
through the process
-
Finance
FAQ
-
Finance
creates amended legislation
-
TFSA
creation in 2008 budget
-
Notice
of Ways and Means in
a Press Release March
11, 2026
-
Explanatory
Notes in a Press Release
March 14, 2026
-
Parliament
posts Bill
-
TFSA
included in Bill C-10 January
27, 2026
-
Received
First Reading in
40th Parliament 2nd
Session which
commenced January
26,
2009
-
Follow
the status of Bill C-10 at
Status of House Business
-
Open
the Bill to read it under House
Government Bills (list of Bills
C-10)
Once the
Bill is passed and the Senate
approves the Bill, Justice amends
Income Tax Act and adds Regulation
5000 and 5001 to describe Prohibited
investments to TFSA's
Long
before the Bill is passed, CRA acts
like the law is already in place in
order to create the forms, guides,
publications, and systems to
administer the TFSA as if it is law
already
-
CRA
advises Registered Plan
Administrators about TFSA
-
CRA
advises individuals about
TFSA
-
CRA
creates publication RC4466, an
information sheet and advises of
other publications that may have
an impact (see bottom of RC4466
where IT Bulletins and Form
RC240 (not yet created) are
listed)
Where to
find information about income
tax:
-
Site
Map
-
Forms
and publications
-
Online
services
-
Individuals:
-
Child
and family
benefits
-
Being employees
-
What
to do when someone has
died
-
How
to report on a trust and
what types of trusts
there are
-
Business
hires an employee
-
Landlord
reports rental income
-
Investor
accounts for capital gains on
sale of investment
-
Seniors
-
pension
splitting rules
-
CPP,
OAS, GIS
-
Self
employed persons
-
Keeping
records
-
Records
-
Business
Records
-
GST/HST
-
Persons
with Disabilities
-
Corporations
-
records
employee
taxable benefits
-
files
T2 corporate tax
return
-
Non-Profit
Organization reports
-
Charity
reporting and whether or not an
organization is a charity
Where to
find information about court
cases:
-
Law
student assist taxpayer with
research about a landmark
Supreme Court case on how to
read the Income Tax Act (Canada
Trustco)
-
www.Canlii.org
Assessment
Knowledge
/
Understanding
Does
student demonstrate
-
awareness
of major
concepts?
-
understanding
of major
concepts?
Thinking
and
Research
Does
student
-
use
major tax concepts in an
insightful
manner?
-
make
links between major tax
concepts that are strong
and
relevant?
-
understand
how to use the CRA
search engine and site
map?
Communication
Can
student organize and present
major tax concepts
effectively?
Does
student use "tax language"
to research
queries?
Can
student determine when they
require more information and
contact CRA help to ask for
more
information?
Application
Does
student complete and
document
appropriately:
-
TD1
for employee with T4
income, a spouse, one
child or a parent over
65 who lives with
them
-
A
T4, T4 Summary and
ROE for an
employee
-
Self-employed
income schedule
including
asset acquisitions,
vehicle and home office
cost
claims
-
Rental
income schedule
-
Capital
gains Schedule
-
Investment
Income Schedule
-
Medical
expense claim
form
-
Donation tax
credit claim
form
-
Tuition
and education claim and
S11, BC S11 transfers to
spouse, parent,
grandparent
-
Child
care
expenses
-
Child
fitness tax credit claim
Course
introduction
Who
plays a role in the
establishment of our
laws?
-
Politicians
-
Finance
Department
-
Parliament
-
Senate
What
are the laws?
-
Federal
Statutes
-
Provincial
/ territorial
Statutes
-
Municipal
By-Laws
Where
do we find information?
-
Canada,
Provinces/Territories
-
Finance
-
Parliament
-
Justice
-
Statistics
Canada
-
Industry
Canada
-
Canada
Business
-
FINTRAC
-
Proceeds
of Crime, Money Laundering
& Terrorist Financing
Act
-
Canada
Revenue Agency
-
CanLII.org
Who
enforces the law?
-
Auditors
-
Officers
of the Courts
-
Courts
Administration
Service
-
RCMP,
provincial or local
Police
-
Attorney
General
-
Judges
via the Court system
-
Jail,
fines, penalties
Why do
we need law?
-
Social
order
-
Public
programs
-
Services,
infrastructure
-
Protection
from harm
How do
social policies and federal tax
laws define acceptable financial
behavior?
-
Self-assessing
system in Canada
-
Ignorance
is no defence,
-
Guilty
until proven innocent
-
Expected
to know and comply with
law
Activities
to engage in to protect
ourselves from harm:
-
Education
-
Keeping
records
-
Planning
to minimize taxes
but
only if our planning does not
step over GAAR General
Anti-Avoidance Rule (since
1995)
Section
245 of the ITA
IC
88-2 GAAR -
IC
88-2S1
G500-6-9
GAAR and GST
IT
News on GAAR reviews -
2005
Decided
cases to search for on
www.canlii.org
-
Kaulius
(loss transfer - SCC)
-
Desmarais
(surplus strip)
-
CECO
(partnership / disguised
proceeds)
-
OGT
Holdings (QCA - Quebec
shuffle)
-
MacKay
(avoidance loss transfers -
FCA March 2008) leave to
appeal to SCC sought,
decision delayed until after
Lipson
-
Landrus
(non arms length loss
realization - TCC May 2008)
under appeal to FCA
-
Remai
(charitable donation - TCC
August 2008) under
appeal
-
Lipson
(attribution - SCC January
2009)
Watch
for decisions on:
-
MacKay
(SCC)
-
OGT
Holdings (QCA)
-
Garron
Family Trust et al
(TCC)
-
Collins
& Aikman (TCC)
-
Lehigh
Cement (TCC)
INCOME
TAX ACT AND
REGULATIONS
Part
1
-
Division
A - Liability for tax S.
2
-
Division
B – Computation of
Income S. 3-108
-
Division
C – Computation of
Taxable Income S.
110-114
-
Division
D – Taxable income
earned in Canada by Non
Residents S. 115-116
-
Division
E – Computation of tax
S. 117-127
-
Division
F – Special rules S.
128-143
-
Division
G – Deferred and other
special income
arrangements S. 144-148
-
Division
H – Exemptions S. 149
-
Division
I – Returns,
assessments, payments
and appeals S. 150-168
-
Division
J – Appeals S. 169-180
Part
1.1 to XIV Other Taxes
included in S. 180.2 –
219
Part
XV - Administration and
Enforcement S.
220-244
Part
XVI - Tax Avoidance S. 245,
246
Part
XVI.1 - Transfer pricing S.
247
Part
XVII – Interpretation S.
248-262
Regulations
RESEARCH TAX
TOPICS:
1.Keeping
Records
2.Students
3.Employees
4.Employers
5.CPP
and EI
6.Business
7.New
Business
8.Industry
Canada
9.Self-employment
or partnership
10.Corporations
11.Employee
benefits
12.Capital
Property
13.Capital
gains
14.Rental
property
15.Principal
residence
16.Investment
income
17.Retirement
18.Tax
Free Savings Account
19.Marriage/Partnership
20.Separation
/ Divorce
21.Support
22.Personal
Tax Credits
23.Line
300- 378
24.Child
and Family Benefits
25.Persons
with disabilities
26.Social
assistance
27.Seniors
28.Death
29.Trusts
and Estates
30.Consequences
and Convictions
RESEARCH:
ADMINISTRATION OF
TAX
Keeping
Records
—Tax
Returns (some major
categories)
—T1
(Personal)
—T1Adj
—T2
(Corporate)
—T3
(Trusts &
Estates)
—T4
(Payroll)
—T5
(Interest and
dividends)
-
Tax
Schedules
-
Topic
list: Guides, Forms and
Publications
-
Document
Types
-
Client
groups
Representation
Security
of Taxpayer Information
epass
Enabled Services
CRA's
electronic services
overview
Individual:
T1013
-
Level
1 allows CRA to disclose
information to the
representative
-
Level
2 allows the representative
to request changes to your
tax returns
Note
Level 2 authorization does not
permit changes to your basic
information such as your
address, identification, marital
status, direct deposit or 8
digit code
Who should
you give authorization
to?
Consider carefully
whether to provide Level 2
authorization
Adjusting
your tax return may be
accomplished by letter, Form
T1-ADJ or online in My
Account using a change
request.
Business:
Contact
person/representative
-
Form
RC1 Request for a Business
Number - provides for
Contact Person only - must
complete an RC59 to
authorize a
representative
-
Pamphlet
RC2 - The Business Number
and your CanRev
Accounts
-
Form
RC59 Business
Consent
Form
-
Level
1 review information
-
Level
2 allows the
authorized person to
make
changes
-
Note:
Unlike Individual
representative, if you
don't choose a Level for
Business the default is
to Level
2!
Adjusting
your corporate tax return
GST/HST
Rebates
CPT139
CPP/EI - Authorizing or
Cancelling a
Representative
Internet
Security Tools
Canadian
Legal
Information
Institute
CanLII
is a
non-profit
organization
managed by
the
Federation
of Law
Societies of
Canada.
CanLII’s
goal
is
to
make
Canadian
law
accessible
for
free
on
the
internet
CanLII
is
testing
a Beta
version
that
will
enhance
the
delivery
of
legislative
material,
currently
Federal
statutes
and
regulations
and some
provinces
are
available
with
more
coming
online
shortly.
More
useful
links:
Financial
Literacy and Education
Summits
(sponsored
by Visa)
April 20,
2025
April 19,
2025
Aplril 4,
2011
CRA study
on youth and taxes
Financial
Consumer Agency of Canada
AICPA
Financial Literacy website
BC
Education – IRP Resources
BC – Education –
Planning 10
University
of the Fraser Valley
BC
Securities Commission
Canadian
Banker’s Association
Industry
Canada Youth Initiatives
Employment
standards – school corner
(BC)
Links to
more TaxDetective webpages:
Financial
Literacy Tool Kit
What's
New 2009
What's New
2010
What's New
2011